Washington, DC Independent Media Center : http://dc.indymedia.org
Home
Washington, DC Independent Media Center

Re: Re: DC Central Kitchen; Stadium Groundbreaking

guy, no reason to be a smart ass. It really doesn't aid in discussion, as it serves to insult rather than educate. If it makes you feel better, I feel small now, and duly insulted.

Anyway, I do see that you missed my point and we have begun and argument based of trivialities. you're playing a game of analyzing my words rather than reading my message. This serves no purpose, since i garner that we probably wish the same thing for our city in terms of helping people. Maybe i'm wrong and you're just being insulting for its own sake.
either way, I apologize for not being the wordsmith you seem to require.

To believe that the city makes back the money they put into social serices is beyond my comprehension. do you think this can put the city in the black? I use the words "return of zero" to express "net" rather than "gross". If you were not just looking to disagree, you could have easily seen that, rather than attempt to engage in a semantical argument. I don't believe there is one page of data to represent this because it is completely accepted that there is no net profit in social services. that is not their point. They are not a business and do not generate profit/loss statments as such. The budget of the department of human services is around 50 million a year. I don't believe that human services track the stats of people no longer utilizing their funds. Do you believe that the taxes generated from these programs equal 50 million?

To think that one can become a brain surgeon from city funded schools and social programs is also incomprehensible to me. perhaps you know of programs i don't, and perhaps they should be more well know to the general public. perhaps the 50% of public school kids that actually manage to graduate from dc schools could utilize these.
for info on schools and money in dc, i point you to the information here:
dcedublog.blogspot.com/
there is a lot of info there, and you are free to puruse what you'd like.

or perhaps you were,again just arguing sematics rather than substance. if that is the case, you are right, my wording wasn't comprehensive enough.

for economic impact of the stadium go here:
app.cfo.dc.gov/services/fiscal_impact/search.asp

i not sure why you say I'm likely so proud of the welfare to work program. moot, really.

you seem to indicate that i have changed positions. Have I? i believe i'm still saying that a dollar for dollar comparision is not an equivalent comparison.

are you really interested in this discussion, or just having an argument?
 
Add a new comment
Title
Author
Text Format

Comment

Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.

Comments

Re: Re: Re: DC Central Kitchen; Stadium Groundbreaking

So, how is this different than a kind of trick down economics, which shows repeatedly that whatever growth you see on the overall scale of the economy, that it typically only further stratifies society between the haves and the have nots.

Isn't there always some other gigantic public works project on the table such that even if anything ultimately trickles down it does so at a rate that keeps only the contractors prosperous?

Maybe, the city is better off with a much lower tax base if it means that the basic services of people in the city are met or at least are as fair as can be to all who have a stake in the city. Perhaps, it is better in the name of ending class stratification that we as a whole (taken as a gross sum - pun intended) so that more as individuals do better.

That will cause it's own set of problems, but at least it will be our problems for us to solve and not the problems for those who hold the keys to solve.
 

Account Login



Forgot your password?

Media Centers

Syndication feeds

Views

This site made manifest by dadaIMC software