Washington, DC Independent Media Center : http://dc.indymedia.org
Home
Washington, DC Independent Media Center

Re: The Rand Study and CM David Catania Call for the Misuse of the Tobacco Fund / The Continuing Mortgage Lending Scandal

"I'm not spamming. I've posted it in two threads"

Except that neither thread was about audio compression.

"There is no way to play MP3 files in the US without breaking the law"

Oh, really?
Tell me, which law(s) do you believe are broken when you play an MP3 file?
(Copyright laws involving pirated music excepted.)

"or using non-free software."

Are you kidding?
There are hundreds of free applications to play MP3s.

Pretty much every OS comes with one pre-installed, unless you are unfortunate enough to be stuck with Lunix.

"Ogg/Vorbis isn't patent-encumbered,"

Which means absolutely nothing to the end user.
Unless you are in the business of selling hardware to encode/decode audio streams, patents and licensing are non-issues.

"and furthermore, it achieves better compression and quality."

That depends on the bitrates.
At 128Kbps (which the OP used) or higher, modern codecs are statistically tied in perceived quality in public listening tests.

"If you want people dedicated to freedom to listen to your audio, provide it in a format that can be played in the Free World."

That would be MP3, which is playable everywhere.
It certainly isn't Ogg.
Post your files in Ogg and you have just limited your audience to only the most tech-savvy of readers.
 
Add a new comment
Title
Author
Text Format

Comment

Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.

Comments

Re: Re: The Rand Study and CM David Catania Call for the Misuse of the Tobacco Fund / The Continuing Mortgage Lending Scandal

Playing MP3 files without a license to use MP3 breaks US patent law (I'm not sure about the situation in the EU, but it could be similar). Patents in the US (and US proxies) can and are applied to software concepts, such as the GIF compression scheme and the MP3 codec.

"Public listening tests" have no bearing on true quality.

By clicking the link in the button, you can get an Ogg-supporting media player, even for your toy windows "OS". Ogg is universally supported even outside of the Free World. But since you seem to be an advocate of non-free software and non-free users, I'm going to stop this. Fascists like you aren't to be talked to, they're to be smashed.
 

Re: Re: Re: The Rand Study and CM David Catania Call for the Misuse of the Tobacco Fund / The Continuing Mortgage Lending Scandal

"Playing MP3 files without a license to use MP3 breaks US patent law"

Prove it.
Cite the relevant sections of patent law.

"'Public listening tests' have no bearing on true quality."

Double-blind listening tests are the only scientifically and statistically valid method of judging perceptual quality of lossy audio compression techniques.

If you disagree, why don't you tell me which method you prefer?

"By clicking the link in the button, you can get an Ogg-supporting media player, even for your toy windows "OS"."

I have a Mac.
Strange that you would call Windows a toy, as it is used in most work situations.

"Ogg is universally supported even outside of the Free World."

Ogg is like betamax.
Marginally better quality in some situations.
But hardly anyone can play it.

"But since you seem to be an advocate of non-free software and non-free users"

LOL
I use free software every day, as do most people with a computer.
Nice non-sequitar though.

"Fascists like you aren't to be talked to, they're to be smashed."

Are all Ogg zealots as violent as you?
 

Re: Re: Re: The Rand Study and CM David Catania Call for the Misuse of the Tobacco Fund / The Continuing Mortgage Lending Scandal

you are trying to scare people by pretending perfectly legal behavior violates patent law, and threatening to smash someone?
who is the real fascist here?
 

Account Login



Forgot your password?

Media Centers

Syndication feeds

Views

This site made manifest by dadaIMC software